Is going to the Ohel and saying Yechi a contradiction?
By Rabbi Shloma Majeski
Topics: Rebbe
Question
Is going to the Ohel and saying Yechi a contradiction?
Answer>
I think what people mean when they ask this question is: how can you say that the Rebbe is alive, and still go to the Ohel? Is that not a contradiction? And the answer is no, it is not a contradiction. Let me explain.
The basis for saying that the Rebbe continues to live is from the Rebbe's own sichos and the way he spoke about the Previous Rebbe: that even after his passing, he's here and he's alive. And the Rebbe based his words on the Gemara. The Gemara says in reference to Yaakov Avinu, "Yaakov lo mes"—Yaakov never died. And it says the same about Moshe Rabbeinu (in Gemara Sotah): "Moshe lo mes."
But people ask, "How could you say such a thing? There was a funeral?!" And the answer is, well, that's exactly what the Gemara is saying. The Gemara itself points out that there is an explicit pasuk, a verse in the Torah, which says that Yaakov was buried. So why did they bury him? Why did they embalm him? Why did they eulogize him if he's alive? And the Gemara, knowing full well that Yaakov was buried, still maintains that "Yaakov lo mes." Of course, there are a lot of details to this and it needs much more time, but the general meaning is this: the facts are facts, Yaakov was buried, but the Gemara reveals to us that what happened was not the opposite of life.
The same is true of Moshe Rabbeinu. It's interesting: if one looks at the commentary of the Rambam to Mishnayos, in his introduction, he writes that on the seventh of Adar something happened to Moshe Rabbeinu which appeared as if he passed away. In other words, the reality is that these facts did happen, but the meaning of what happened was not the opposite of life.
So what kind of life is it? What is he doing? How is he functioning? And the answer is, of course, WE DON’T UNDERSTAND, because we're talking about something which is totally, completely beyond the realm of nature, something which is only found by selected tzaddikim, not even by every tzaddik. In fact, it's interesting to note that even when tzaddikim—like Moshe Rabbeinu or Yaakov Avinu, or other tzaddikim of this caliber—were alive and functioning, and we saw them, we also didn't really know how they were living. We thought we knew, we thought we understood. Two famous stories show this.
The first is with Reb Nachum of Chernobyl, one of the greatest students of the Mezritcher Maggid and a great tzaddik in his own right. His students once said to him, "We would like you to show us a hidden tzaddik." So he said, "Look at me." And they said to him, "You? You're not a hidden tzaddik, you're a revealed tzaddik." And his answer was, "Woe to me if I was what you see." Which obviously means that what he was, and what he was involved with, was way, way, way beyond anything we can see and comprehend.
The second is with Reb Adam Baal Shem. The Baal Shem Tov refused to reveal himself—initially he was a hidden tzaddik—and Reb Adam Baal Shem was chosen to encourage him that he must reveal himself, that the time had come. There are a lot of details to the story, but one of them is especially interesting: the Baal Shem Tov was in shul listening to the Torah reading, and while he was there, Achiya HaShiloni, who used to study Torah with him, walked into the shul and told him that after Shabbos they were going on a trip. (Who is Achiya HaShiloni? He was a prophet who lived in the times of Eliyahu HaNavi, and even earlier.) Nobody saw a thing, nobody heard a thing; they saw him listening to the Torah reading like everybody else.
So can we understand how tzaddikim live? Do we have any idea what they're experiencing and what they're doing? It says about the Baal Shem Tov—and again, this is based on the Gemara, which says that tzaddikim really live in two worlds, down here and also up there—that during the week he was two-thirds in this world and one-third in heaven, and on Shabbos he was two-thirds in heaven and one-third in this world. So it's a different kind of life completely.
And therefore, even though one goes to the Ohel—yes, something occurred, and because of that there is a need to go to the Ohel—what occurred is not the opposite of life, and "Yaakov lo mes." Just as it applies to Yaakov, to Moshe, to Rabbeinu HaKadosh, and all the others, that's how it applies to the Rebbe.
I would also think that some people are referring to the announcement of Yechi—when people say "Yechi Adoneinu Moreinu V'Rabbeinu Melech HaMoshiach L'olam Va'ed." But the truth is that if you look at the source of that, the Rebbe is the one who initiated announcing "Yechi HaMelech," in the famous sicha of Beis Nissan, 5748 (1988). The Rebbe says that saying these words has a tremendous spiritual power, and—these are the Rebbe's words—"Hakitzu v'ranenu shochnei afar," "v'yakitzu v'yiranenu Dovid Malka Meshicha": it brings the awakening of Melech HaMoshiach.
So if anything, the words of Yechi are of course relevant and powerful now, even though at the same time one can go to the Ohel. Because we know that the Rebbe is here, he's alive in a hidden way, and what we're saying is that he should be revealed and take us out of galus, teikef u'miyad mamash.
Watch the companion video episode
Back to Blog