What are we waiting for if we are told that Moshiach is already here?
By Rabbi Shloma Majeski
Topics: Moshiach, Rebbe
***
Question>
The Rebbe said countless times that Moshiach is already here. So if he’s here, what are we waiting for?
Answer>
The Rebbe actually said this numerous times, especially in the year 5751 (Tof Shin Nun Alef), after the Persian Gulf crisis began and during the Persian Gulf War. The Rebbe quoted the Yalkut Shimoni—the Midrash—which says that in the year Moshiach will be revealed, there is going to be a war in that geographic location we know today as the Persian Gulf, and the whole world will be frightened. Yet Hashem will send a message to the world: "Nothing to be afraid of, do not panic—it’s all because the coming of Moshiach is imminent." And the words of the Midrash are: "That is the year that Moshiach will be revealed."
The Rebbe then said many times that Moshiach is already revealed—and not only revealed, but that Moshiach is already making changes in this world.
So the question is: How can you say that when there are so many unfortunate things continuing to happen in the world, just like before?
To understand this, we can look at something similar that serves as a precedent. When the Jews were in Mitzrayim, the one who brought redemption to the Jewish people was Moshe Rabbeinu. We don't use the term Moshiach there, we use the term Goel—the redeemer. At which point can we say that Moshe Rabbeinu was revealed as a redeemer? Once he came to the Jewish people and said, "God sent me to take you out of Egypt"—at that point, he was revealed.
Once that happened, did it mean that all the pain, suffering, and slavery stopped? The answer is no. Not only did it not stop, but the Chumash itself—not a Midrash, the Chumash itself—says that things actually became worse than before. They became so bad that Moshe Rabbeinu turned to Hashem and said, "Lama harei'osa—Hashem, why did You even send me? You made things worse." And it took a while—according to some opinions, a year and a half—before the Jews actually went out of Egypt. The slavery continued, and things got worse before they got better.
What do we see from this? That the coming of the redeemer is one thing, and taking us out of golus—out of exile—is a second thing. The same is true with Moshiach. Certainly they are connected, and certainly Moshiach brings redemption, but these are two separate stages. One stage is when the person Hashem appointed as Moshiach is revealed and identified as Moshiach, and the next stage is when that person takes us out of golus, and all the suffering, pain, and everything else ends.
In fact, the Chiddushei HaRim discusses what appears to be a contradiction. One place in the Gemara says that if a person declares, "The day Moshiach comes, from that day onward I become a nazir and am prohibited from drinking wine," then every single day he is not allowed to drink wine, because maybe Moshiach will come today. Yet another source says that the redemption will take place either in the month of Nissan or in the month of Tishrei—which makes it seem as though it cannot just happen on any day.
Here is his answer: Moshiach coming can happen on any day, and therefore the person is not allowed to drink wine. Redemption, however—meaning when things are changed in the world and the suffering is over—is designated for either the month of Nissan or the month of Tishrei (even though we have heard from the Rebbe many times that even that could happen at any moment). Clearly, he uses the example of Mitzrayim: Moshe Rabbeinu being revealed as a redeemer is stage one, and taking us out of exile and ending the suffering is stage two.
Therefore, it is not a contradiction to see ongoing suffering in the world and still say that Moshiach is already revealed. In fact, the Rebbe went as far as saying that Moshiach is not only revealed, he is already making changes in the world. And the fact that we see a movement in the world toward turning swords into plowshares and ending wars is a direct result of what Moshiach is already accomplishing in a spiritual sense.
Watch the companion video episode
Back to Blog