Why Bigger Prizes Make Kids LESS Motivated
By Rabbi Mendy Wolf
Topics: Inner Life, Education
***
Question>
Between school, programs, and home, it feels like our kids are constantly getting prizes just for doing what they're supposed to do. Are we over-rewarding our children and making them spoiled?
Answer
I am going to say something that might make you laugh, but hear me out. Why do we have to give prizes to children? Who said you have to give them prizes?
You might say, "What do you mean? Of course children need prizes!" And it is actually in the Rambam: Le'olam yehei—a person should initially learn lo lishmah (for an ulterior motive, like a reward). Even adults need some kind of lo lishmah.
However, there is a famous sicha where the Rebbe recounts a story about the Rebbe Rashab as a young boy. He was crying and asked, "Why didn't the Aibishter show Himself to me the same way Avraham Avinu saw the Aibishter?" The Rebbe shares that if this story was told to us, it means there is a lesson we can take from it. The Rebbe explains that a child possesses a certain purity and emeskait (truthfulness) that adults, who have become somewhat corrupted by the world, no longer have. A child has the natural ability to ask for goodness and truth—and actually wants it.
Wait a second—if that is true, why do we need to give them prizes?
Here we have two discussions, almost like two different roads of motivation. On one hand, you are telling me a child has this purity and the ability to genuinely want to do good for its own sake (lishmah). On the other hand, you are telling me the child needs prizes. Is this the same Rebbe speaking the same language? At the very next Tzivos Hashem rally, the same Rebbe says to make sure the children get a prize and move up in rank! What is the explanation here?
The Rebbe explains that it comes down to what you say to the child while you are giving them the prize. You tell the child: "Yingele, meidele, you don't really need a prize. Your yetzer tov naturally wants to do what the Aibishter says. You want to learn the Aibishter's Torah—after all, who doesn't? There is no kuntz (trick) with you. However, I know you also have a yetzer hara and distractions. So let me help you. This prize isn't for you; the prize is just to quiet down your distractions."
In this moment, the child is listening to the two voices within himself, and you are speaking to both of them. You are allowing the child to experience and understand his own internal struggle. The child actually feels that truth. He thinks, "Yeah, you're right, I do want the Aibishter's Torah, but it's hard to get out of bed and it's hard to learn. Oh, so this prize is going to help me get out of bed!" The child understands that the prize isn't the endgame; it is simply a tool to quiet his distractions.
That is the discussion we need to have, and that is why we give prizes. Context is everything. It is not true that the bigger the prize, the more motivated the child will be. In fact, if you have the proper conversation, the child will be much more motivated because you are speaking to him truthfully: "I know what you truly want, and I know you have distractions, so let me help you overcome them."
Once we put prizes into context, we can address the original question: Are we over-rewarding?
This isn't really a question for schools and organizations; it is a question for parents. As parents, we have to be honest with ourselves. It is very easy to give. It feels so good to say, "I gave to my child—whatever you want, take this, take that."
But what are we doing? We are creating a generation of children who expect—a generation of children who feel entitled. Do we want to do this? What are the long-term effects of endlessly giving to a child?
The onus is on us as parents. There comes a time when we have to implement real motivation and have a genuine discussion with our children rather than just throwing prizes at them. Tell your child, "Really, I'd love to give you everything." Then, awaken within them the desire to do good for the sake of good, to step out of their comfort zone and do something difficult. When they say, "But it's hard for me," you can respond, "Ah, so I'll give you a prize to help with that."
When you approach it this way, you have a completely different relationship with rewards. It won't be an endless pit where the more you give, the more they demand. Instead, it becomes a content-driven, mission-oriented discussion.
It is hard work, but that is how we build character, resilience, and real children. And guess what? Schools and organizations will be more than happy if we parents take the lead and lower the bar, because we don't need these extra, super-fancy prizes. When one child comes to class with an extravagant prize, it changes the atmosphere for the entire classroom. It affects everyone.
We cannot just look to the organizations; we have to look at ourselves. If all of us as parents take this approach and have real discussions about prizes, it will create a ripple effect. Everybody will be happier, and our children will be even more motivated—because a "yes" means so much more when there is also a "no." You have to be able to say "no" to truly appreciate a "yes."
Watch the companion video episode
Back to Blog