Do You Owe Maaser on Stimulus Checks and PPP?
By Rabbi Mendel Zirkind
Topics: Halacha
Question
Do I need to give Maaser from the stimulus and PPP programs?
***
Answer
I think there are three different elements to this question. I think there's the question of whether one is obligated to take off maaser, should one, even if they're not obligated take off maaser, and is even one allowed to take off maaser. We should differentiate also between the stimulus checks versus the PPP.
In halacha when it comes to the obligation to take off maaser, which is somewhat different than the obligation of tzedakah, which we may do in a following video to discuss more about tzedakah and its obligations. But when it comes to maaser, the obligation to take off maaser is only once one has enough of their own necessities. Exactly what does that entail? Obviously rent, food, etc. There is a criteria, there is a certain list of things that one could include as their necessities, and anything beyond that would be, then would be the obligation to take off maaser, whether before taxes or after taxes. But that's when one is obligated to take off maaser.
So when we're talking about the stimulus checks, most people who are getting stimulus checks are based off low income, at least that's what they claim on their taxes. Low income families who need the money for basic necessities, paying bills, etc. They may have lost their job. And all of those things, all of the basic expenses, and a person if people are in debt, you use your money that you have to pay up the debt. You use your money to pay up your rent, etc., etc. And only whatever you have after, whatever is left after, would you have an obligation to take off maaser.
With that said, people obviously who this extra money is just that, it's a little extra money, but they have enough, then for sure there should be an obligation to take off maaser, being as the halacha is any gift one gets, when it comes to maaser one is obligated to take off a tenth or perhaps as the Rebbe says maybe 15% of any earnings or any gifts, any form of financial income that one receives.
When it comes to the PPP however, since the government's program is a loan, at least that's the main objective, is to help small businesses keep hiring workers, employees, etc., being a loan, a loan is not obligated to take off maaser, because the money is not really yours. The money eventually is going to have to be given back. Now the government definitely has created room for people to work through a certain system that they do not have to pay back the money. Even with that said, it could be argued for a number of reasons why one would not be obligated to take off maaser in those cases.
Number one, maaser is only based off a revach. Once one, a certain amount of profit that one makes. Let's say in a person's average year, they usually make a hundred thousand dollars of profit, so obviously you have to take off maaser from that, etc. But if someone is in the loss, is in the loss, he's in the red, so then he has, he's losing money, so then the maaser, the obligation to take off maaser wouldn't begin yet because the money that he's getting is not real profit, it's not real revach. And therefore in this case it could be argued that the small businesses that are really in desperate need of financial help seemingly would not have to take off maaser because it will not be considered real revach.
Furthermore, there is the din that when it comes to maaser, when someone gives you money and tells you that this money is for a specific use, so then you would not have an obligation and you wouldn't perhaps even be allowed to take off maaser unless you ask them explicit permission. So food stamps for example, since the government is giving this as money specifically for food, we are not allowed to take off maaser from it because here the money is being given for a specific purpose. Here too in the stimulus, the PPP, the money is supposed to be given specifically to hire more workers, more employees, to retain the employees you have, etc., to stimulate the economy. They don't want this money to be given to charity.
A third reason is the issue of geneivas daas. The Rema points out that if a person, if the government gives money, and they give you a specific purpose for the money, so then you could be cheating the government by using the money for another purpose, even if, even for charity, there could be a problem of geneivas daas, of cheating the government in this case.
So this would be the general halacha when it comes to taking maaser from the stimulus and so on.
One point just to mention, the Rebbe very much encourages every person, all of us to take off maaser even if we're not really doing too well financially. And especially when it comes to a situation like that we're in now with the coronavirus and the need for a big refuah, a big yeshua. So the Rebbe says that tzedakah, and again tzedakah and maaser are not exactly the same but definitely in this case fits together, tzedakah can help b'mevatel gezeiros. So with all that we should try to the utmost that we could to give as much tzedakah as we could. And for those who have the means and the ability to give they should give and give perhaps more than usual. And through this perhaps, and not just perhaps, the Aibershter himself says b'chanuni na b'zos, test me, and you'll see the promise, you'll see the yeshua, you'll see the refuah, you'll see b'ezras Hashem we'll see the geulah amitis v'hashleimah.
Watch the companion video episode
Back to Blog