The Real Reason Behind Chanukah Gelt
By Rabbi Yosef Katzman
Topics: Chabad Customs
Question
It seems common in the broader Jewish world to give Chanukah gifts, but I have noticed that Chabad exclusively gives Chanukah Gelt. Can you explain the reason for this?
***
Answer
The Rebbe always spoke about giving Chanukah gelt as a matter of chinuch (education)—specifically to train children to give tzedakah (charity). The idea of giving Chanukah gifts actually comes from outside influences, as a way to compete with the traditions of other cultures.
While the Rebbe may have addressed the topic of gifts versus gelt more directly elsewhere, his message was consistently focused on 'gelt' (money). The main purpose was always to give children money so they could learn the importance of giving to charity.
***
Editors note*
I would just like to add this firsthand story to beautifully illustrate the Rabbi's point about the Rebbe's deliberate use of the term "gelt" rather than "gifts." This account from Chanukah 5752 (1992) shows how the Rebbe insisted on the traditional terminology even in the most extraordinary situations.
In Kislev of that year, following the Rebbe's directive, Zalman Chanin and his group traveled on a monumental mission to Russia to print the Tanya in places of profound historical significance. With the help of Reb Zev Wagner and Reb Avigdor Pruss, they miraculously managed to print editions in the very jail cell where the Alter Rebbe was imprisoned, as well as in the former Leningrad apartment of the Rebbe Rayatz.
Against all odds, Zalman Chanin and his friend Reb Leibel Zajac rushed back to New York just in time for Chanukah with 62 freshly bound editions of the Tanya. They arranged with the Rebbe's secretary, Rabbi Yehuda Leib Groner, to leave the heavy bundles for the Rebbe to take to the Ohel. Instead, Rabbi Groner stunned them by announcing that the Rebbe wanted to see Zalman and Reb Leibel in a rare, surprise yechidus (private audience) to present the books directly to him.
As they handed the massive bundles of sacred books over to him in his holy room, the Rebbe smiled broadly and thanked them. But when describing this priceless, historic “present”, the Rebbe didn't refer to it as a Chanukah "gift." Instead, he made a point to use very specific terminology:
“Noch a mol, a groysn dank. Dos iz di beste Chanukah gelt vos a Yid ken krign.”
(Once again, thank you very much! This is the best Chanukah gelt a Jew can receive.)
Moments later, after discussing the printing costs with Reb Leibel, the Rebbe repeated it to emphasize the point:
“Dos iz di greste Chanukah gelt vos a Yid ken krign.”
(This is the greatest Chanukah gelt a Jew can receive.)
Even when receiving something that would typically be considered a Chanukah gift, the Rebbe explicitly referred to it as Chanukah gelt—perfectly demonstrating his consistent perspective on the holiday's traditions.
Watch the companion video episode
Back to Blog