Chalav Stam = Non-Kosher?
By Rabbi Noam Wagner
Topics: Halacha
Question
Is eating Non-Chalav Yisrael the same as not eating kosher?
***
Answer>
So I think it's first very important to bring out a point which a lot of people make a mistake in. A lot of people say, 'Well, the whole reason that we need to eat Chalav Yisrael is just in case they mixed in non-kosher milk into it.' That's incorrect.
The Torah gives us two aspects. There's min HaTorah (mid'oraita) and there's mid'rabbanan. Things which are Torah laws and things which are rabbinical laws. The rabbinical laws are just as important and even more important. The Gemara tells us, 'Chamurim divrei sofrim yoter mi'yena shel Torah' [The words of the Scribes are more stringent than the words of the Torah]. The rabbinic laws are even more important than the Torah laws. To the extent that the Rambam writes that in a Torah law, it's either a positive commandment or a negative commandment. When it's a rabbinic law, Hashem told us both a positive—listen to what the rabbis tell you—and a negative—don't steer away from what the rabbis told you.
The concept of chalav akum, of milk that was milked by a non-Jew and a Jew was not watching at the time, is something which the rabbis instituted as a rabbinic law. Which means it's not kosher. Not because there may be non-kosher milk mixed into it, but because that's what the rabbis instituted—is that this is not kosher because it itself is not kosher. And that's something which is important to remember. That's the concept of chalav akum. It's a halacha in Shulchan Aruch, it's something which is brought down all over in the Jewish law.
Now, to go in short about the idea of, whether if I'm sure and certain that a non-Jew... didn't mix in non-kosher milk into it, can I then say that it's alright? So there's one opinion, and that's the Radbaz... Rabbi David ben Zimra, he says that the rabbis instituted it for a reason, and if the reason doesn't apply—for example if it's very expensive non-kosher milk, or if it's not available non-kosher milk, there is no non-kosher milk to be found—he says that then it would be allowed. The Pri Chadash follows him... he says that in Amsterdam, the Portuguese community relied on this leniency of the opinion of the Radbaz.
However, that was in that time, in the time of the Radbaz and the Pri Chadash. Today, all the rabbis, both Ashkenazic rabbis—the Ashkenazic rabbis first of all say that the Radbaz and the Pri Chadash were both Sephardic rabbis and therefore it doesn't apply because all the Ashkenazic rabbis say different. However, the Sephardic rabbis also say that the Radbaz and the Pri Chadash were only one opinion, and today everyone follows the opinion that it doesn't matter if it's available or not available, because it's a gezeira, it's a decree that the rabbis made and they had their reasons for the decree. And once they made it, it's not kosher. It's a rabbinic non-kosher.
Now, there is a heter [leniency]. There is a heter from Rav Moshe Feinstein. A very famous heter, and I'm not going to go into it now. But if someone wants to follow that heter, that means they follow all the opinions of Rav Moshe Feinstein as well... which include also things which are stringencies. If he's your rabbi and you follow him, that's one thing. And the truth is, even if he is your rabbi, Rav Moshe Feinstein himself writes that a ben Torah, someone who's careful about Torah, shouldn't eat non-Chalav Yisrael and shouldn't rely on the heter. And he writes, interestingly enough, he says, 'I myself don't rely on it.'
To the extent that he says something which is an original concept. And that is usually, when someone, for example, will be careful to eat glatt kosher meat... most of us are careful with that. If you cook in the pot non-glatt kosher meat, you're not allowed to kasher the pot, you're not allowed to say 'I don't want to eat from being cooked in the same pot' because then you're saying someone else is eating non-kosher, that's forbidden. Nevertheless, Rav Moshe Feinstein himself, the one who made the heter about Chalav Yisrael, says that if you're careful about Chalav Yisrael—which includes himself, because he writes that I myself am careful... he says that if you're careful about it, then even the pots and even the keilim, even the utensils that were used for non-Chalav Yisrael have to be kashered. You're not allowed to use the utensils that non-Chalav Yisrael was cooked [in] because it's considered by Rav Moshe Feinstein, the one who made the heter, non-kosher.
Now obviously for a Lubavitcher, we're ba'asrei d'rav, we follow our Rebbe. And our Rebbe didn't follow this heter, didn't believe that it's a leniency. In fact, the Rebbe is very, very strong about Chalav Yisrael. To the extent that the Rebbe says it causes sfeikos in emunah, it causes questions and doubts in faith when a person eats non-Chalav Yisrael. And it causes all types of things, many times the Rebbe spoke also about physical health, that keeping Chalav Yisrael is going to help someone also in physical health.
So it's obviously a Lubavitcher follows the Rebbe and there's no way whatsoever of having a heter. Those who do follow Rav Moshe Feinstein, they should follow also what Rav Moshe Feinstein says, which is that it's best for someone to yes be careful, and that he himself was careful about it. And therefore to actually be careful to the extent of realizing that the keilim themselves, the utensils with which non-Chalav Yisrael was cooked, cannot be used and they have to first be kashered in order to use it for other milk.
Watch the companion video episode
Back to Blog